Hip Strain
By Edie, The Salsa FREAK
www.SalsaFreak.com
www.SalsaWeb.com
www.DanceFreak.com
Also See:Right
Hip Pain Article
Major Concern:
What are we Teaching?
“So what’s this wind-up prep again?” A student
asked me at the last event.
As instructors, we teach
what we’re taught.
As instructors, we teach
what we see works.
As instructors, we always
try to do the right thing.
As instructors, we are
responsible for the health and well being of our students.
Well, I’m writing this article to do just that. Do
and teach the right thing.
There is an epidemic going around in the Salsa
community. It is happening to the hips of people who practice a
“coiling-up” type of wind-up preparation of the body prior to high-speed
multiple spins. The problem is inflated when improperly preparing prior
to a double spin or more.
My Own Experience:
I would experience the most excruciating pain on my
right hip at the point my body completely relaxed while falling sleep.
. The pain was so severe at night that at times I would have to cry
myself to sleep. After taking up to five Advil per night, I realized I
had to do something.
My doctor told me that the pain on my right hip was
the tendon acting like a rubber band that had been stretched too far.
The pain was from the tendon shrinking back to its original size. This
de-stretching of the tendons is what caused so much pain at night, or
while sitting still.
Because I fly to a different country virtually
every weekend, for several months I asked dancers from all over the
world if they had experienced the same type of pain I was going
through. If I was prepping to spin like they were, I couldn’t be the
only one! When I started talking about it, I was shocked and amazed at
how many of the top dancers in the world were going through the same
pain I was - coincidentally at night, just prior to falling into deep
sleep! Some of them went through much worse pain. The age range of the
dancers questioned started from 22 through 50. Age was definitely not
an issue in this study.
I then decided it was my duty as an international
instructor and ambassador of this dance, to figure out how to get to the
root of this problem, and fix it once and for all.
THE PROBLEM
When a person preps for a turn they are taught to
wind up the opposite direction first. This is normal. The abnormal
aspect of the preparation however is the placement of their feet during
that preparation.
In ballet and ballroom, we are taught to point he
toes outward. If we nail our right toe to the ground (to maintain this
toe-out look) while we prep the rest of our bodies and hips to
the left, the result is a slight strain on the right hip. If we do this
often enough, and with enough force and power, the tendons end up
stretching out of place. If we continue this type of preparation
throughout the night, over and over again, night after night, week after
week, and month after month, we will develop a permanent problem that
will never go away – unless WE change.
My biggest problem was actually getting over the
habit. It felt good doing this type of prep while dancing On Two.
However, I ended up also applying it while dancing On One. When we
dance On One, women have one less second to prep for the turn. When we
dance On Two, women have a bit more time for the preparation. This
extra time has allowed Two-Dancers to develop beautiful hip styling on
the back rock of Salsa. On One Dancers have emulated this, but the
result is a rushed look because of the split second less time we have to
prep – thus forcing the strain that much more.
Fortunately, I learned this type of preparation
AFTER I created my World Famous Spins DVD. Thank God I did not teach it
in the DVD. When I created that DVD, I did not have any hip problems.
It wasn’t until a few months after I learned this new prep that I
started experiencing pain. When I was looking for the solution,
I
actually had to go back to watching my own DVD to see exactly how
I was preparing, the correct way.
THE SOLUTION
First. Practice the new way of prepping for a
spin. Study my Spins DVD on how to prep. (I had to go back and
re-learn the correct way from MY OWN TAPE).
Just to be sure that what I was doing was
correctly, I went to instructors whom I respect that weren’t
experiencing any hip pain. I analyzed their turns and asked them for
advice and instruction. Susanna Montero from the UK, Jamie Josephson
from New York, Nari from Korea, Rioko from Japan, Maribel Maldenado from
New York, and Joby Martinez from Los Angeles. Gypson Pierre from
Singapore gave me some incredible insight into the prep from the
theories of ballet. All of them gave me slight variations in what they
do.
To eliminate the confusion, I will break it down
into a simple solution.
Your
toes must point the same direction as your hips and knees.
If you prep to the left, point BOTH your toes to
the left. If you prep to the right, point BOTH your toes to the right.
Susanna Montero is an amazing dancer / instructor
that has never experienced any hip pain. Susanna preps completely
differently when she dances On-Two, than when she dances On-One. When
she preps On One, she simply plants her right foot to the ground, and
spins on her right leg. Her left foot never touches the ground coming
forward. When she preps On-Two, she points both toes to the left prior
to spinning to the right. She never twists her entire body.
Another professional dancer is Jamie Josephson.
Jamie is an avid On Two dancer who has never experienced any hip pain
either. Her trick is to tighten her thighs together and place 50% of
her weight on each leg during the preparation, prior to the spin.
Again, both her feet are pointing the same direction as her hips. Jamie
uses her shoulders to help her with speed.
Another dancer / instructor is Maribel Maldenado
from New York. Maribel does not twist her body prior to multiple
spins. She keeps her hips facing forward and uses her free arm and
shoulders to help with the power and speed of the spin.
Gupson Pierre from Singapore has also given some
fabulous insight into the preparation from a ballet standpoint. His
theory is the same. Point your toes the same direction as your hips. I
will be featuring an entire interview / story on his research and
findings on the subject (he sent me a TON of info... Thx Gupson!!!)
Nari from Korea, and Rioko from Japan have also
studied the prep turn. Interestingly enough, they both point both their
toes to the left prior to multiple right turns. This eliminates the
strain on their right hips.
Fixing the Immediate Pain - NOW:
You now understand that you’ve got to change the
way you prep. But for now, the pain in your hip is unbearable, and you
need to get to sleep. What can you do NOW that will stop the pain
tonight? This is what I’ve done that works.
MSM Lotion
You can get this special
lotion at your local Health Food store or on the Internet. I rub MSM
lotion on my hip prior and after dancing, and just prior to sleeping.
I’ve recently discovered that it also helps sore and achy feet! Try
rubbing MSM lotion on your feet before you go to sleep. Your feet will
LOVE you that night, and the next day!
Advil and/or Ibuprofen
Sometimes the pain was so
severe I used to take up to 10 Advil per day. Now I’m down to none.
Thank God! These types of medications thin the blood, so you want to
keep them to a minimum.
Prayer
Prayer really works.
Pray to just fall asleep peacefully. You will be shocked and
amazed at the results.
Try Dancing Cuban
Style for a while.
Once I started partnering
with Henry Herrera of Cuba / Miami, the pain subsided dramatically! I
literally took a two-month break from linear dancing on accident, and
ended up not experiencing any pain after dancing Cuban style for a
while. I couldn’t believe it! There are no high-speed multiples in
Cuban style, so there is no need for a prep – much less a poorly
prepped, prep!
How the Guys Can Help:
Spin Us Both
Directions.
Why aren’t guys giving us any more multiple
LEFT TURNS anymore? They USED to do it all the time years ago, and now
they’ve simply just stopped. I’ve analyzed my dancing lately, and I’m
constantly being spun to the right, to the right, to the right, over and
over again. HEY GUYS. We do go LEFT ‘ya know! It would
be a NICE BREAK to give us multiple spins to the LEFT again. I don’t
know what happened. Constantly spinning us too much to the right all
the time adds to the unnecessary strain on our right hips.
Give Her One Less
Spin.
Not every woman is a
Ferrari. Dance at her level. If she can’t do a double, a nice
single is beautiful and more relaxing – FOR THE BOTH OF YOU. If she can
do triples, great. But remember, triples the entire song puts a strain
on her hips. Guys, try putting your SELF into a few triples during that
song. Women are extremely impressed with men that do their own turns
and spins during the dance. There is nothing cooler than seeing my
partner do a double or triple while he’s partnering with me – holding my
hand at the same time (not just solo!). Putting your selves into
doubles and triples is super impressive, and less stress on the girls.
It’s deflating to see the guy just standing there and orchestrating the
woman to do ALL THE TURNS AND SPINS the entire time.
Spin Her a Tad
Slower.
We can only spin so
fast. When spinning us, don’t make the circle you make with your arms
above our heads so small that only our arms end up moving and we slow
down, losing our frame. Give us ample time to prepare, and start
spinning us at an even pace – in the pulse of the music. Spin us to the
beat of the song, and pulse the spin to our natural speed. You will
feel it. Spin her at her speed. You will feel her natural rhythm. The
problems start when you try to force her to spin faster than she is
physically able. She should help you with the power of the spin by
using her shoulders and free arm, but only after you’ve prepped
her well and securely. Remember that she cannot go faster than what she
is used to, and you cannot force her to go faster. If she is forced
to spin faster than what she can, you will accidentally strain her hip
and do a severe blow to her ego and self worth. This will make her feel
doubly bad.
Give Her Enough
Time to Prep
I can’t tell you how many
times a guy attempts to spin me more than three times simply by raising
his arm then forcing me to turn fast before I get a chance to step
forward and prepare for the turn. There is a certain amount of time
required to prep us for spinning. It is about a second and a half.
That’s it. But that second and a half is “oh so important” for us to
prep appropriately and safely. Honor that, and we will give you a
FANTASTIC multiple spin. (Correct preparation samples are in my Spins
DVD). Give the ladies ample time to prepare for the spin by remembering
that we turn AFTER we place our left foot forward toward you (left or
right multiples, the rule is the same). We don’t necessarily have to
transfer weight completely, but our left leg should be well on its way
to coming forward prior to your spinning us.
Hip Strain is caused by a poor preparation prior to
multiple spins. The solution is simple. Point your toes the same
direction as your hips during the prep. The immediate solution to ease
the pain is a light pain medication, proper diet, and MSM lotion. The
long-term solution is education. Kicking the habit is the hardest
part. We need to make a conscious effort to do so, each and every time
we spin.
Feedback and Letters from Hip-Strain
Sufferers all over the world:
I was so happy to read your article about right hip pain. I have
the pain in my right hip joint. Since I couldn't pinpoint exactly
what was causing it, I was beginning to panic. My mind was
thinking all kinds of things. You can imagine!!! My husband is a
chiropractor and treats me almost daily. We never thought of the
pain being related to dancing. He was getting a little frustrated
because the joint didn't stay set after so much treatment.
Although, I am a beginner to Salsa, we have been into right turns
a lot. I was out of class for about two weeks, and now I look
back and recall the pain was almost non existent during that time
frame. Oh well. Since I love Salsa, I guess I will just continue
to get the chiropractic treatments. It is the only thing that
helps. I add 3 aspirins along with the chiro treatment and I am
good for another round of dancing.
At least I know I am not alone in this.
Thanks for the article.
Hi Edie,
I read your article on salseras with right hip pain on
the Salsa in the City website this morning. I have
experienced this as well in the past and ended up taking
time off from dancing, I thought I just had hip issues!
Please include me on your e-mail list when you send out
more information. I would greatly appreciate it and so
will my hip!
Thank you.
Sincerely,
Angel Knoedler
|
Hi Edie,
I am getting better with the
acupuncture and electrotherapy. I have been
doing it for about 2 months now 3x a week and I
have begun dancing again. I don't feel the
strain half as bad now! Though my hip is still
stiff, (that's because of the cartilage tear,)
the pain has significantly reduced and I don't
need painkillers at all! I am also taking
glucosamine 3000mg a day. Doctors tell me it
helps with joint problems but takes about 3
months to take effect. There's another japanese
lotion that I find works real good for muscle
aches. It's called Yoko Yoko. I don't know if
they have it in the states. It's like a
colourless liquid and you just put it on and
let it dry. more effective than any
ointments/balms I've ever used before. .
Rgds, Lani
|
Dear Edie,
I read your most
recent newletter and was so
surprised that this was a problem
affecting lots of people. I thought
it was only me. I am from Jakarta
Indonesia and have been dancing
salsa for about 2 and a half years.
I dance jazz and salsa almost
everyday. I've had R hip pain for 2
years now and it gets so bad at
night sometimes I can't sleep well.
Most people tell me "you are dancing
too much, slow down, you're getting
old." 2 months ago I went to consult
with several orthopaedic surgeons in
singapore. The news was not pretty.
Apparently, I was born with a
dysplatic R hip which means that the
hip joint is not positioned
properly. Because of this, I have
developed early osteoarthritis and
with so much dancing, a tear in
the cartilage in the R hip.
Unfortunately, the tear in the
cartilage of the hip is something
that surgeons are not willing to
treat, unlike a tear of the
cartilage in the knee that can be
treated surgically with an
arthroscope. Anyway the long and
short of it is they tell me that I
will need a hip replacement sometime
in the future. What I am trying to
say is that this problem of hip
strain if not corrected may cause
serious injury to dancers as is the
case with me.
I also wonder
whether this is a problem with
salseras who do a lot of spinning
which I do. Do the people who dance
cuban style have this problem?
As for the
solution... I have not permanent
solution at this point. I am
reducing the frequency of dancing,
getting acupunture treatment and
doing pilates to relax the joint and
strained muscles. Hopefully I
can delay the hip replacement for
at least 10 years or so.
Best regards,
Lani
|
I got to thinking I ought to just tell you what I have done so
far
(since it is working for me) but I will have to be brief. I will just
go through my written list real fast...
*In order to do 4 hours of massage a day, I have to get at least one 50
minute full body massage a month, and at least one 5-10 minute neck and
shoulder massage a week to keep going. I usually trade with someone to
save money.
* I try to get chiropractic done about once every 6-8 weeks, sometimes
less, sometimes more, but definitely, if I throw something out, it
keeps me going. I would be in a wheelchair without it. He gives me a
slight discount cuz I am a cash patient and my husband works for a
church so we don't make a lot of money. Also, if I am in a bind, he
trades me for massaging his wife.
*I have never done accupuncture, but it has helped a lot of my friends
and family. But I do the lifewave patches which accomplish the same
thing. They have been the final touch that have taken me from being 70%
better, to about 90% better, in terms of pain. But they also have
increased my energy, my focus, my strength and my endurance, and have
given me the hope that I will be able to keep being active as I age,
and maybe even do the triathon I had made a commitment to do before I
hit 50. I was getting depressed and feeling very old before I found
them a few weeks ago!
*Orthotics is the next thing I am going to try, when I have the money.
*Getting more sleep has been crucial for my recovery since the body
rebuilds why you sleep, but I was having trouble with insomnia until
the Lifewave sleep patches. Now I sleep deeper, dream more vividly,
fall asleep sooner, etc. becuz of higher delta waves and oxygen levels,
and so wake up more refreshed. I also try to dance a little less, not
so late at night, not so long of periods of time, etc. It has made a
great deal of difference, and I thought I would miss it more, but I
keep myself busy with a good book on days I take off from dance, so I'm
okay. I had to do a little letting go. Life needs to be balance,
including those things we are passionate about. There is a balance
betweeen focus, which helps us excel, and whipping ourselves and
disregaring our boundaries, which wears us out. I also gave up caffeine
in any form after 5 PM, and that made a difference as well, as it takes
me 5-6 hours to relax after consuming it.
*The Epsom salt and Masters Miracle Baths always make me feel so much
better and more relaxed! I have been using the salts for many years,
they are tried and true! Heat packs and ice packs alternating
(especially frozen peas), are also helpful when I remember to use them.
I don't like using ice alone, it makes me to tight.
*I have always relied on prayer to get me through, and time spent in
the Word, meditating on it, as well as time spent in nature, just being
quiet and listening, have been very helpful to my thought life and
peacefulness, as well as decision making.
*I have been going through some personal things, that have needed help
from a counsellor/ psychotherapist, and so she has been very, very
helpful, especially with things I did not understand, that went way
back and had caused me problems for a long, long time.
*Changing my diet to 50% or more raw produce (with its naturally
occuring minerals, phytonutrients, enzymes, alkaline pH, and high water
content) with a lot of greens (for good protein) added to my smoothies,
and about 90% vegetarian has made me feel younger and more energetic
and had taken me from about 40% well to about 70% better. Prior to
that, increasing my minerals and cleansing the heavy metals had taken
me from almost dead with a major disease, to about 40% well.
*Core muscle exercize (in particular, sit ups and some weight lifting,
which are both quick to do, 20 minutes minimum a week is all it takes
if you do them slow enough, 14 seconds per rep) I got behind on, becuz
of my health problems knocking me down repeatedly. I am trying to get
them strong again, and when I do, they make all the difference in the
world in terms of my back not going out as much, and my speed, agility,
balance, coordination, grace, etc being sharper and dance, and any
sport really.
So this has been my journey so far. I do hope you find some things that
reduce your pain and create better balance, greater health, wellbeing
and peacefulness for you. Blessings to you! Kathi
The two books I am looking into that I think would benefit you
are...
**Trigger Point Therapy- A Visual Guide to Techinque, by Clair Davies
**Chiropractic Self Help for Back Pain by Samual Homola
Of course, you can always come see me at Burke Williams Day Spa in
Mission Viejo and get a massage. But meanwhile, pray about each thing
here and see if God gives you some direction.
Hope you find something of use in all these! Kathi
DanceKatW@aol.com wrote:
I am a dancer, tho I only do a bit of Salsa, I do a lot of dance
(mostly West Coast Swing, but also all other dances, Lindy, East Coast,
Ballroom, Country, Latin.) I have taught 6 sports (ice skating, snow
skiing, gymnastics, soccer, volleyball and personal training), and am
currently a Massage Therapist. I am 48 years old at this point and very
active. Without seeing how you are winding up to spin and being able to
give you specific pointers, I would like to toss out some general ideas
to check out in your search for answers.
I will start with a list of things you can do before each paragraph,
and then comment on why you might want to do those things.
MASSAGE THERAPY, CHIROPRACTICS, ACUPUNCTURE, LIFEWAVE PATCHES,
ORTHOTICS. First of all, pain comes from several sources- one is
tension, which can be relieved through massage therapy for muscle
imbalance, or chiropractics for bone misalignment, or acupuncture for
energy imbalance. Often tension comes from something we do over and
over again, which can be the type of dance or sport we do, the way we
sleep, the way we work, etc. Our posture starts to take on the shape
that we move, sit, stand or sleep in several hours a day, and parts of
our body's begin to shorten while others begin to lengthen. Golfers,
Bowlers, Baseball and Tennis players, etc, get twisted, and I can
usually see a twist happening in their backs when they come to see me
and lay down on my table. In West Coast Swing, my left hip goes back
over and over again on my anchor, and I am thinking it is effecting my
back/hip in a similar way to what you are describing, tho I control my
pain becuz I take care of it through massage and chiropractics, etc. on
a regular basis. But my chiropractor recently mentioned that my left
arch is collapsing and that is causing my knee to twist and my hip to
drop when I walk or run, so I keep popping my fibula out (which causes
pain in my knee when it happens) and the dropped hip is causing me to
develop scholiosis (s curvature of the spine). So it is possible that
the feet, knees and hips are also all being affected in your senario as
well, especially due to the high heels often worn by salsa ladies. I am
looking into getting orthotics made to support my own arches, which I
never thought I would need since I have such strong feet and high
arches. Acupuncture is a great reliever of pain, but for those who are
nervous about needles, I found a product that works in a similar and
effective manner to balance the energy of the body. I have been having
such success with them, that I now distribute them. They are Lifewave
Energy Patches, that tell the body to burn fat, create energy, stamina,
strength, focus, and relieve pain (all the things I need as a Massage
Therapsit). They are approved by the Olympic committee becuz nothing
enters the body, and they are being used and researched across the
country by a large number of people at most major universities and on
major athletic teams. They also have available Sleep Patches that tell
your body to create more delta waves, and put more oxygen into your
brain, so you sleep deeper and heal more while you sleep. I won't go
into all that they do for you here, but if you want more info, check
out my website by pasting the website address below into your address
bar, or email me your questions.
www.lifewave.com/katw
SLEEP, REST, RELAXATION, BATHS, MIRACLE SOAPS, PRAYER, MEDITATION,
COUNSELING, PSYCHOTHERAPY (just make sure you only get help from
someone really good if you seek counseling of any sort)- Another cause
of back tension can be emotional/ psychological/ spiritual. When you
have a lot going on in your life that is causing you a lot of negative
emotions like grief, anger, anxiety, etc, you might go dancing a lot to
unwind, relax, let go, forget, etc. but the tension might still be
there. There might be a need to relax more, to pray or meditate, to
take some time off, or talk to someone wiser than you about things. But
dancers often do not want to take time off, they push themselves to the
limits! I know, I do. Dance at that point may be more of an addiction
or crutch, tho a healthy one at that, but maybe the better thing to do
is to take some time out to deal with the problem you are experiencing
rather than avoid it. Maybe you need to make some life changes, like
get away from an abusive relationship or a job that has a very negative
environment. Maybe you need to consciencely give things to God in
prayer or get away to a quiet place surrounded by quiet and nature. We
need to listen to our bodies and take care of them. We need to make
sure we rest them, and stretch them, and maybe soak in a hot bath on
occasion. If it is a strain, then you need to stop dancing and let it
heal. But most of us do not want to listen to that wisdom. Here are
some of my favorite things to put in a bath. One of the best soaks for
sore muscles is Epsom Salts. They are cheap and you get them at any
drug store and some markets, in the first aid department. They usually
come in a container that looks like a milk carton. I put 2 cups in a
bathtub filled with the hottest water I can stand and I stay in
optimally 40 minutes or more (take a good book to read with you, or
listen to some music). It takes 40 minutes for the blood vessels to
come to the surface and fully release their toxins and take in the
nutrients. Epsom salts are magnesium, which is a mineral that is a
muscle relaxant. (You can also take a good calcium/ magnesium
supplement to reduce pain from the inside out, and make the body more
alkaline. I recommend the citrate version. More on that next
paragraph.) Take a washcloth or loafa sponge in the bath and scrub down
your body while you are there and your skin will feel wonderful and
your muscles will get a bit of a massage! For additional relaxation,
add some pure essential oils like lavendar/and or orange. But don't add
regular soaps or fragrances, most of them are chemicals and harmful to
the body, and definitely not things you want to soak in. Anything put
onto the skin of the body is in every organ in the body within 1
minute, make sure it is beneficial. If you want to use some soaps that
are made of all natural ingredients, mostly minerals, that cleanse,
alkalinize and detoxify your whole system, then check out my other
website below where you can get The Masters Miracle Soaps. You put 1-2
ounces of Neutralizer and 1 ounce of either green Soap in your bath and
soak 40 minutes. All kinds of wonderful things happen when you do, but
I don't have time to go into them right now. Write me if you are
interested, or order directly online. I personally alternate between
the Miracle Soaps and the Epsom Salt baths. (Oh, and by the way, their
Mineral Deodorant Spray is terrific for eliminating food odor by
spraying it on your feet before you go dancing.)
(there is no www in the address)
http://katw.themastersmiracle.com
DIET, ENZYMES, MINERALS, PH, HYDRATION- What you do inside yourself is
very important in terms of pain reduction. Many dancers/ athletes
forget how important it is to hydrate themselves and to eat properly.
It seems as tho, when we are young and in good shape and our muscles
and skin look good and we have energy, that we must be healthy. But the
body can only go just so far on exercise alone. If you are not
replacing lost minerals, lost water, lost nutrients, then your body is
going into a negative state, and that is going to start taking its
toll. You need to eat raw fruits and vegetables and their juices!!
Everything else you put into your body creates an acid pH. Only raw
fruits and veggies, with a couple exceptions like cranberries) create
an alkaline pH. That is becuz of minerals. Raw means that they have not
been heated above 116 degrees, have not been processed, nor microwaved,
and so their nutrients are intact and unaltered. The enzymes also are
not destroyed and therefor the food is far more absorbable. We need to
eat a diet that is no less than 50% raw produce, otherwise you are
going backwards nutritionally. At 65% raw, there is an energy explosion
in the body. Plus, eating a raw food diet will help you to stay
hydrated, or as one friend put it, you will be juicy. That is the
difference between youth and age- youth are more juicy. Again, I don't
have time here to go into all that, but it is certainly worth studying
if you want to remain healthy, energetic, young looking and pain free.
Pain is nothing more than a bunch of chemicals in a place that ought
not to be there. They can be waste products from stress, or from
injury, or from energy or nerve blockages, or from putting things into
the body that don't belong there. A muscle that is not hydrated will
not contract properly. If it cannot contract properly, it can get
injured. Sweating, alcohol, soda pop, tea, coffee, chocolate
(caffeine)... these are all things that dehydrate us.
CORE MUSCLE EXERCISE- Lastly, if you want to keep from getting injured,
then you need to make sure your core muscles are strong and balanced.
Dance does work the core muscles generally speaking, but not
necessarily evenly. Basically, if you are an advanced dancer and very
graceful and strong, you probably have developed your core muscles.
But, it is possible you have an imbalance if you are doing only one
kind of dance, and if one body part is used more, it may be stronger
than another part. You are only as strong as your weakest link. Social
dancers ought to be doing either ballet, pilates, yoga, ball exercises,
or gymnastics if they want to keep limber and balanced. And they may
need to do full body weightbearing workouts with dumbbells that
includes situps to keep the muscle strength balanced. I know that
especially when I was teaching the various sports, I had to make sure I
took care of my own strength and flexibility outside of the sport
itself, or I started to lose my edge in the sport.
Sorry I do not have time to go into more details, maybe someday I will
write a book on this subject of pain, but for right now, I hope this
gives you some things to look into and that you find the solution you
are looking for to you and your student's back pain.
Sincerely, Kathi Wormald
Edie~ Thank you for your personal reply, that is much
appreciated! I
have had a passion for health and fitness since I was 14 (34 years now)
and have studied a great deal on the subject. (Note that I attempted to
take 34 years of research and put it into one email, which does not do
the information justice). I do suggest you print out what I sent and
try things that interest you that I listed, one at a time. For example,
Epsom salt baths are cheap, but very effective. (Under $4 for a box,
and you can get several baths out of it.) Only you will be able to tell
what will work for your body, and God will guide you. Injury and
disease are often caused my multiple factors, so it usually takes
multiple remedies to get well. Taking pain pills or putting things on
the skin that relieve pain, do not deal with the cause, they only numb
you to what it really happening in your body. You cannot tell what is
working if you drug yourself, tho I do know what excruciating pain is
like, and you may have to slowly wean yourself as you find things that
really work. Pain pills work in the body to distract it by causing side
effects that are worse than the condition you are experiencing,
therefor, your body stops paying attention to the other problem and
focuses on the new one. I wish I had time to tell you more, but you
have enough to check into and experiment with. I have been doing all
these things, and I am finally 98% out of pain for the first time since
the original accident that disabled me for 10 years. I can only say
that each one works to a certain extent, and that each one combines
with the other for greater benefit.
I also wanted to let you know about two books I just discovered and
ordered due to the recommendations I have been receiving about their
helping people in pain. Thought you might like to go on amazon.com and
look them up, and read what people had to say about them....
I will include them in the next email since I have to go to another
browser to look for them, and it is requiring me to send this email
now. Kathi
Dear Edie,
Tonite after salsa class, I told my instructor, Joe
Figueroa, that I have been having terrible
LEFT hip pain while dancing. I have only been studying
salsa for 6 months, and find that
when I dance with a partner who is either much more
advanced than I am, or who is
dancing very fast, I seem to push myself hard to keep up
with him and immediately
thereafter, feel pain in my left hip. This happened
tonite & happened Saturday nite
at a big salsa dance. The pain has stayed with me. Joe
mentioned your article & so
I am writing you in response to that.
It was a relief to see that it isn't only beginners who
are suffering! But it is upsetting,
because of the thought of continuing a dance that causes
so much pain. I also wondered
if it was due to my age (I'm 55) but I'm in very good
physical shape and walk every day,
so I didn't expect this. Then I wondered if it was due
to the fact that the hips are used
so strongly in salsa, as compared with other dances.
I am an acupuncturist and have been using Traumeel, a
homeopathic cream that helps
somewhat. Ibuprofen and aspirin have not done much for
me. I've also slept with a
heating pad, which led me to another idea. In
acupuncture, we use an external herb,
mugwort, which is rolled into a cigar shape & burned,
then held over the area of pain.
This process is called moxabustion and is usually very,
very helpful. I am going to
start using it and see if it works. In addition, I'm
going to try some of my Chinese
herbal linaments that you apply topically. I'm also
going to figure out a protocol of needles to
use on myself to help with this pain. I'll let you know
what I discover.
I eagerly await your next article on this subject. Feel
free to contact me if you'd like
to share any ideas, and you may use my name & comments.
Regards,
Donna Greenberg
|
Hi, Edie.
My name is Erin Brandt and I live in NYC. Do you have any video
online
of the specific prep you use before the outside/right turn that causes
this pain?
I do movement analysis for a living, and would be happy to take a look
at the movement, analyze it, and offer a suggestion for a slight change
in the movement, or an exercise/stretch combo to balance this pattern.
Let me know if you would like some help. I am happy to offer it.
Sincerely,
Erin Brandt
Dear Edie,
I read your most recent newletter and was
so surprised that this was a problem affecting lots of
people. I thought it was only me. I am from Jakarta
Indonesia and have been dancing salsa for about 2 and a
half years. I dance jazz and salsa almost everyday.
I've had R hip pain for 2 years now and it gets so bad
at night sometimes I can't sleep well. Most people tell
me "you are dancing too much, slow down, you're getting
old." 2 months ago I went to consult with several
orthopaedic surgeons in singapore. The news was not
pretty. Apparently, I was born with a dysplatic R hip
which means that the hip joint is not positioned
properly. Because of this, I have developed early
osteoarthritis and with so much dancing, a tear in
the cartilage in the R hip. Unfortunately, the tear in
the cartilage of the hip is something that surgeons are
not willing to treat, unlike a tear of the cartilage in
the knee that can be treated surgically with an
arthroscope. Anyway the long and short of it is they
tell me that I will need a hip replacement sometime in
the future. What I am trying to say is that this problem
of hip strain if not corrected may cause serious injury
to dancers as is the case with me.
I also wonder whether this is a problem
with salseras who do a lot of spinning which I do. Do
the people who dance cuban style have this problem?
As for the solution... I have not
permanent solution at this point. I am reducing the
frequency of dancing, getting acupunture treatment and
doing pilates to relax the joint and strained muscles.
Hopefully I can delay the hip replacement for at least
10 years or so.
Best regards,
Lani
|
Hi Edie,
Appreciated your article on the right hip pain. I have
been suffering with it for over a year, and have had to
stop dancing. I'm also a chiropractor with plenty of
access to treatment, but it just does not resolve. Now
it is shifting to my left side, and goes back and
forth. Any suggestions would be appreciated, so I may
resume my dance classes. I'm glad to know I'm not the
only one. i know when it happened, I went dancing for
five hours straight, and that was enough to put me over
the edge. i have beautiful dance shoes and I just look
at them and feel very sad that my dancing days may be
over.
Sincerley,
Dr. Susan Bobak
Edie,
Interesting topic and I had this injury for a while and
identified the
general cause when I took time off from salsa to spend
time outside
this
summer. The pain had not become debilitating and it
would persist
whether I
iced or stretched. I decided to take a break from salsa
and the hip
pain
went away and I enjoyed a break with some outdoor sports
(then golf
tweaked
my lower back so I have to swim, too). I feel better to
know that this
is a
common experience with preventative measures and hope to
learn what
those
preventative measures are. Thanks for watching out for
us. Caryn
Hi Edie
Girl you sure do hit the things that matter. Sitting
here in pain when
your email arrived and I thought great, it's not just me
getting old and
falling to bits. Working out a solution through better
technique and general
care sounds like the go. I'm only doing single
right turns (have your Spins
DVD and am practicing more then one) but lots of them
during an evening of
class and social. Then the pain kicks in for the next
day. I've also
found that my toe joints seem to ache after a big
session to. Finding a
solution sounds good to me can't have anything stopping
the fun. Or just take a
pill.
Regards Diana
PS Hope to meet you at the UK Salsa congress.
|
Edie-
Hi it is me Andrea in L.A. Congratulations
on your move to Florida and continuing to be
a model and motivation for all
SALSERAS!
Just wanted to let you know that I do that
infamous "NY prep" (snake wind up), whatever
you want to call it, rather intensely,
especially now since my dance team is
preparing for the MAYAN dance team
competition. No one on my team has had any
problem in their hips. Sounds to me like
this problem stems from a weakness in the
muscles surrounding the hips. I am not a
chiropractor, only an aerobics instructor
for five years, so I am no expert. But
what I do know is that when you are
over using one part of the body where the
muscles are weak, the opposite muscle
compensates.
I would highly suggest yoga to all salseras.
I started it over 2 years ago and have
noticed no sore or tight muscles from
dancing. What yoga does is strengthen and
stretch all of your muscles and work on
balance. Basically that is what you need to
be a good salsa dancer, aka-a strong core.
I got really nervous when I read your
newsletter about the hip thing
because ANYTHING that jeoprodizes
my dancing scares me! LOL! I really hope
we get a handle on this "epidemic". Good
luck, I hope my information helps someone.
we really miss you in L.A.,
hope to see you soon, Andrea
Edie,
You don't know me. But hey,
everyone knows you! And I
admire you as well. I have
your videos. And you are the
only Salsera that I stop
dancing and actually stand
and watch.
Anyway...re: the right hip
pain article...
I'm so glad you published
that article. I have been
treated with acupuncture for
it.
And it helped a lot. The
first question my doctor
asked was...are you dancing
a lot?
I've also had acupressure
massages as a followup after
acupuncture.
Now I know I'm not just
getting old and crazy.
Thank you.
Josette
|
|
Edie - Good to talk to
you the other day. Just FYI - in my series in 1985, I
had a column on preventing injuries. The one dealing
with knees had to do with tightening the weighted foot -
all the way up through the buttocks - to make sure that
the knee and the toes are pointing in the same direction
on a spin or any kind of rotation - and that the toes
are spread so that the knee does not torque. The one on
the hips went into great detail about why any type of
hip movement, including rotation preparation, needed to
come from the abdominal and core muscles. Hips that are
rotated vigorously from the legs and bent knees have a
tendency to pinch nerves at the base of the spine and
lead to all kinds of hip pain. That was one of the
subjects that I wanted to sit down and discuss with you
because I had seen so many of the Salsa ladies moving
their hips from the legs. I knew it would not be long
before they got into trouble. (International Latin
people have a lot of trouble with that kind of hip pain
because of the way they teach movement).
Thought I should send
you this because, with our schedules the way they are, I
figure it would be a long time before I get to see you.
Your picture on the email looks fantastic. Keep up the
good work!
God Bless and
Love you much,
Skippy Blair
|
Hello Edie,
So how are you ? I
was surprized to see that you left L.A. Well new
opportunities.... I trust all is going well. I'm
Jacqueline , I spoke with you @ your classes in Downey,
about Men ...you had me listen to a disc...do you
remember ? Actually we have talked sevral times...also
in Palm Springs.
I want to wish you the
"Best of Luck".
Well I wish to respond
on the Hip problem. I have pain after dancing on the
Left hip, not the right. In fact @ this moment it is
hurting. Well I did dance last Fri.,Sat. Sun .!! I
always Ice when I return home, & I try to ice before I
go out. I also stretch. My Dr. think, it is a result
of transfer pain from my back because I have problems
here. My trainer believes it is the dancing movements
that are causing it. The hip action.
So what do you think
???
Well take care ....Oh
I enjoy reading you newsletters.
Jacqueline
|
|
Hi Edie,
I am an Orthopedic Massage Therapist and work
with many clients with hip pain, dancers,
golfers, etc. with great success. I am located
in Delray Beach, FL and can be contacted by
email to discuss the matter or schedule
appointments. My primary business is
accomplished through outcalls to my clients'
offices/homes throughout southeast florida area.
Thank you, Shellie
Dr. Shellie
Gretah Fraddin, Ph.D., LMT
 Personal
Health Coach
Transforming
Health and Wellbeing Conversations
Orthopedic
Massage Therapy -
FL License #MA30502
Stress/Management -
Diet/Nutrition -
FitnessTraining - Energy
Medicine - Reiki, EFT
Free
Consultation- 561-495-0644 or 561-702-0570
|
|
Hi Edie,
My name is Alexandra, I was in your spins class on
Sept. 1st. I was the one that declared myself your
biggest fan, and indeed I am. Of course I'm looking
forward to being in your class tonight as well,
especially since I've watched your styling videos
endless times and love them.
But to answer to the article now.
I got better at spins by learning from your video and
from other dancers, but the prep that you were talking
about is what helped me the most and now it almost
seems like I can't do without the prep...it comes
naturally.
I can't say that I have experienced this type of pain
yet, and I hope I will not in the future either, but
that is probably because of the good turnout and
flexibility that comes with a ballet background. But I
was wondering in the spins class why the prep you were
teaching was different than the one on the video that
I learned from. And now it finally hit me, when I read
the article... It is amazing that a teacher cares
enough about their students as well as other female
dancers to bring this up and to change her moves to
better everyone.
Thank you for that!
I look forward in seeing you tonight in class and
perhaps if you have some time, one of these days, I'd
like to sit down for a few minutes to tell you about
the Salsa in Romania and why all the schools there
would give their life to have you come. ;)
Sincerely,
Alexa
Hello Edie,
It was a pleasure seeing you at the
Congress... DIVA!!
I want to address your article. Has anyone
ever questioned that maybe the wind-up, curling up "like
a snake" prep is not proper form nor technique???
I have NEVER, NEVER been an advocate of the wind-up,
curling up "like a snake" prep. First and foremost it
DOES NOT look flattering to the woman and therefore was
not proper technique for me...but then everyone just
want to spin like a top. It breaks any type of line
ESPECIALLY when you're short like me. You don't ever
see a ballet dancer preparing for piruet spins by
winding up, nor do you see Ballroom dancers do that
either....and they can spin. So while it does work to
gather momentum it does not look pretty. I can spin
without having to curl up like a snake and even on one
foot with the "right partner" and therefore do
not experience that right hip problem. My advice...the
ballroom world has great technique, why not take what we
can from there and apply it to salsa. But that's just
my opinion...and you know everyone's got 'em. ;)
Much Love
Maribel Maldonado
|
Hi Edie,
In response to your article about right hip pain, I
was talking with a friend/salsa instructor who
recommends that, during the prep, women angle their
right foot so that the toes point slightly to the
left. This way, when they twist, there isn't a
stretch/strain in the right hip. It's a simple tip
but I've found that it makes spinning a lot more
comfortable. I'm sure you're aware of this technique,
but as a veteran of severe hip pain, both from dancing
and joint affliction, I thought I'd offer what
knowledge I have just in case it proves useful to
other women. :)
Thanks for your time!
Lora J.
"Un grano de poesía es suficiente para perfumar un siglo." -- José
Martí
|
Hi Edie
This is Lia here from Derby in UK - well well, I have had severe almost
disabiling hip pain now for 2 years, my gluteus goes into acute spasm,
I
have pain most days. The doc has even labelled me as disabled as I can
no
longer work at a conventional office pc and desk. I have invested £4000
in
state of the art office equipment. Some days I hobble around
University...
(studying law)
In 1996/97 I has a gym accident on a stepping machine which put my
sacro
illiac out and so, I have been assuming along that my hip pain is due
to
this old injury. When I visit my Chiropractor, he manipulates my sacro,
it
makes a huge noise and then I get an instant let up from the pain but
it
comes back.
I take prescription diclofenac and sleeping pills when its bad, I have
to
put a warm wheat bag on it too to get some sleep. I cannot drive long
distance. I cannot stand still to do dance classes its too painful, I
HAVE
to keep moving!!! I am always telling people my hip is hurting they
must be
sick of me
I have now been to UK's leading physio who works with our england
cricket
team. whilst i dance I has assumed it was the old injury and I did
convince
myself that the dancing had to be good for it because it kept my hip
moving
- You see over 40 I had visions of ceasing - am sure you understand
where I
am coming from.
The best tip I have had is that it is very important to stretch the
gluts
and the inner and rear leg muscles before using the muscles intensely
ie:
for a night of danicng in london or birmingham. This physio has written
down
the excersices and stretches and drawn little stick me to demo each -
Would
you like me to scan these in and send them to you??? it will help give
all
you lady instructors some idea of maybe how we need to be bringing warm
ups
into the dance lesson environment and, if its good enough for the
England
Cricket team and top tennis players here, well its worth passing it
around.
The particular stretch I find good is lying on back with legs straight,
hooking a towel around the foot and pulling the leg up so to stretch
all the
glut and back thigh. The there is also the figure 4 glut stretch.
When tendons over do it without pre stretch they are incredibly
painful, so
even if the hip area is in pain, the pain will refer to the front of
the
upper hip,into the groin and even down tha back of the leg.
I'm not going to be at bognor congress, shame otherwise I would glady
show
you all the excersises that I have only very recently started to work
on
because of the sheer severity of MY problem. I have studied anatomy and
physiology and done remedial sport massage and can advise that there is
also
a pressure technique that is used after excersise to release any
muscles
that may have gone into spasm. Maybe I need to be coming to some dance
weekends and specialising in hip work - any ideas of how I can help
just let
me know.
mail me if you want my stickmen!!! (they don't ansa back)
Any way that aside, spent time with Colin from Southampton, asked after
you
when I realised you'd moved to Miami to work with Henry - Well good for
you
Edie!! You work so hard, I hope the personal aspects of the "moving on
,up
and forward" have been bearable. 8 years ago, I had to make a
break,
different reasons, it was tough but it was RIGHT!! All the very best
Edie
and may an inner strength be with you always.
Stay fit and well - go stretch!!
Lia Jane
Hi Edie
Since the mail below was returned to me I though I would
try the one in your latest newsletter. Hope to hear
from you soon!
BTW re the right hip pain, I used to have that too a few
years ago though I’m not sure if it was salsa related.
I have been doing pilates with reformers and other
polestar equipment twice a week since then and I no
longer have the problem. My pilates physio used to
stretch out my hip flexors for me which was
excruciatingly painful but helped a lot. She said it
was really tight on the right but also worth stretching
on the left! She said that a lot of women have
instability in their pelvises which compounds the
problem. Now I try and remember to exercise them myself
by kneeling on one leg and lunging forward with the
other before and after exercise, not just salsa. It is
not as intense as the stretch from the physio but helps
to keep these muscles supple.
I also see an osteopath once a month or so to maintain
my alignment and to avoid getting into pain (for neck
and shoulders too). I used to see a chiropractor and
persevered for more than a year but I didn’t find this
helpful. My experience is that chiros have you in and
out in 10 minutes and only seem to work on the spine,
whereas osteos act more holistically, and work on your
muscles with deep tissue massage before manipulating so
that your muscles support the alignment. It takes 45
minutes for a treatment but it is much better in the
long run – for me anyway. I am interested to know what
experience others have made. I will watch out for news
in your mails. I think it is a worthwhile subject for
research particularly if you come up with a new way to
prep which can be passed on to instructors to avoid the
problem.
Good luck!
Regards
Allison
|
Hi Edie: You might remember me from the Salsa congress
in Palm Springs last winter as you were so kind to allow
me to take one workshop for free; and you asked me to
help Al at Palm Springs several years ago. I also know
Steven Tondre. I've been a social dancer for 15 years
(WCS and Salsa). Though I don't have right hip pain, I
feel that it might be important for those women who do,
to share a few suggestions. As a medical intuitive and
body/energy worker for 26 years, I have worked with many
people who have all kinds of strain and pain from their
recreation and occupations.
Suggestions:
1) Take Magnesium before you go to bed! Magnesium helps
to relax the muscles, tendons, ligaments and supports
the skeletal system in absorbing Calcium. Most people,
particularly in the US, are deficient in this mineral.
The recommended dosage for Mg needs to be HIGHER than
Calcium, not lower, which is how it is usually found in
the stores. Magnesium was always a higher requirement
until the shortage during WW II. This wonderful mineral
will also help people sleep better and much, much more.
I have even seen it help people with coughing and
congestion so they can sleep through the night.
The form of Mg is very important as is calcium.
If you're Calcium doesn't dissolve in 8 minutes in
water, than it's not absorbable (don't use oyster shell
or calcium carbonate). The most absorbable form of
Mg that I've used and recommend to my clients is Natural
Calm 800-446-7462
www.NaturalCalm.net
2) Find an energy/body worker or acupunturist. The body
energetically responds to such treatments wonderfully,
much better than massage.
3) I'm not going to be well-liked for this suggestion,
but high heels really does a number on the alignment of
the body by throwing it forward and contracting muscles
in unnatural positions. I know ladies like to be sexy
and stylish while dancing, particularly in salsa; and
since dancing is my joy, I'd rather be loving and kind
to my feet and body than be in pain. So that I can
continue to dance until I die, I wear flats with support
or a slight heel not more than 1 1/4 that are wide. So
start to look for stylish lower heeled shoes.
4) Talk to your body parts. Believe it or not, there is
a consciousness to each system of the body along with
unconscious beliefs that are held within them. I know
this to be true because in being a medical intuitive,
I've spoken to these systems in others and myself and
witnessed incredible healings just by listening to what
is needed. Even if you don't feel this will work or
don't feel very 'intuitive' (which we all are), work
with this anyways. We live in times of possibilities and
moving outside of restricted 'boxes.'
There is an emmy award winning fimmmaker and
documentarian named Ben Moses who wrote the book "Talk
to Your Body." (www.talktoyourbody.com
) He has had wonderful results in having conversations
with the bod.
I trust that these few suggestions will be
helpful to those women who are open to them.
Best and blessings,
Judy Dragon
|
Hi Edie
I just read your article on right hip
strain. Good work!
I am a podiatrist practicing what we
in the medical world call Biomechanics. What that
means is that I treat people with hip pain on a
daily basis. I am also an avid On2 dancer, having
just performed at the last LA congress.
I have also, interestingly, been
looking into this hip problem.
Tell me, do any of the persons that
you interviewed complain about their hips initially
making a pain free snapping sound long before
actually becoming painful?
|
|